.svg){kind=small}
ElectricFeel vs Fifteen
An independent comparison of two fleet management platforms to help you choose the right fit for your business.
ElectricFeel
Zurich, Switzerland
Fifteen
Paris, France
ElectricFeel vs Fifteen: What You Need to Know
ElectricFeel and Fifteen both serve the European city-scale micromobility market, but they approach it from opposite sides of the hardware-software divide. ElectricFeel, founded in Zurich in 2012 and rooted in ETH Zurich research, is a hardware-agnostic SaaS platform offering a "Shared Mobility OS" with Incentive Zones for rider-driven rebalancing, battery swapping scheduling for shift-divided crews, and re-engagement campaigns claiming 65% dormant rider recovery rates — built for operators who already own vehicles and want sophisticated operational software. Fifteen, founded in Paris in 2008 and now operating the Vélib' system, is a vertically integrated B2G contractor that manufactures its own electric bikes with magnetic dock charging, deploys ultra-compact modular magnetic docking stations requiring no construction, and manages operations for city governments from Paris to Lima. Fifteen's magnetic docking system — acquired from Zoov — is a physical infrastructure innovation that allows stations to be installed without civil engineering work, a meaningful advantage when bidding on urban public tenders. ElectricFeel is for operators who need best-in-class software atop their existing vehicle fleet; Fifteen is for city governments that want a single turnkey contractor to design, build, operate, and maintain an augmented bike network.
Bottom Line
ElectricFeel wins when a fleet operator needs sophisticated software — incentive-based rebalancing, battery swap scheduling, and re-engagement analytics — layered on top of existing hardware; Fifteen is the right choice when a city government needs a turnkey B2G contractor to build and operate an entire docked e-bike network from infrastructure to day-to-day operations.
Key Differences
Hardware provision
Fifteen manufactures its own electric bikes and proprietary magnetic docking stations with integrated charging; ElectricFeel is hardware-agnostic software, though it has a Segway-Ninebot partnership for operators that need turnkey moped hardware.
Docking infrastructure
Fifteen's magnetic docking system requires no construction or civil engineering work for station deployment — a significant operational and procurement advantage over traditional docking systems; ElectricFeel supports both docked and dockless configurations depending on operator hardware choices.
Operational rebalancing
ElectricFeel's Incentive Zones show riders discounted drop-off zones on the map to self-rebalance the fleet, reducing crew deployment costs; Fifteen manages rebalancing as part of its turnkey operational service for city clients.
Procurement model
Fifteen operates exclusively through B2G public service contracts (no private operator access); ElectricFeel sells to operators across private, corporate, utility, and municipal segments with enterprise SaaS contracts.
Analytics depth
ElectricFeel provides rider behavior heat maps, session conversion rate tracking, data warehouse and BI analytics, and dormant rider re-engagement campaigns; Fifteen's analytics focus on KPI tracking, fault diagnosis, and 24/7 connected monitoring for city authority reporting.
Platform Overview
About ElectricFeel
ElectricFeel is a Swiss enterprise SaaS company spun out of an urban mobility research project at ETH Zurich in 2012, co-founded by Moritz Meenen (CEO) and Pratik Mukerji (CTO, ETH Pioneer Fellowship recipient). With offices in Zurich and Barcelona and an estimated 8–15 employees, they provide a "Shared Mobility OS" covering e-bikes, e-scooters, and moped sharing. Their marquee US client Revel Transit (4,600+ mopeds across NYC, DC, Miami, SF) shut down moped operations in late 2023, eliminating ElectricFeel's entire North American footprint. Their other major claimed client Cooltra (5,000+ e-scooters across 6 European cities) subsequently merged with Dutch competitor felyx — it is unclear if Cooltra still uses ElectricFeel post-merger. Confirmed active clients are Pick-e-Bike (~800 e-bikes, Basel) and Billy Bike (~600 e-bikes, Brussels). Total funding is only ~$1.3–2.2M over 14 years (grants and small investments, no significant VC), with estimated revenue of ~$1.6M. No public API documentation or self-serve onboarding — entirely sales-led.
About Fifteen
Fifteen was created from the 2021 merger of Smoove (founded 2008, docked bike-share systems) and Zoov (founded 2017, magnetic docking e-bikes), rebranding under the Fifteen name in 2022. Named after the "15-minute city" concept. Operates 52,000+ bikes across 30+ cities including 20,000 in Paris (Vlib'), 5,000 in Helsinki, and deployments in Nice, Vancouver, Marseille, Montpellier, Strasbourg, Gijon (Spain), Avignon, and Lima. Raised EUR 40M from Eiffel Essentiel, 2050, and Via iD. Combines Smoove's municipal contract expertise with Zoov's innovative ultra-compact magnetic docking technology. Manufactures all bikes in-house and sells exclusively to city governments and transit agencies through B2G contracts.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Category | ElectricFeel | Fifteen |
|---|---|---|
| Company | ||
| Headquarters | Zurich, Switzerland | Paris, France |
| Founded | 2012 | 2008 |
| Website | https://electricfeel.com | https://fifteen.eu |
| Pricing | ||
| Pricing Model | Enterprise SaaS with custom pricing | Municipal B2G contracts with modular service tiers |
| Starting Price | Contact for pricing | Contact for pricing (B2G only) |
| Scale & Hardware | ||
| Fleet Size Range | 100-10,000+ vehicles | 100-20,000+ vehicles |
| Hardware Provided | No — software only | Yes — bundled |
| IoT Approach | Flexible platform integrating with existing vehicle hardware and transport systems via API. Does not manufacture or sell IoT hardware. Partnerships with vehicle OEMs and smart city infrastructure. R&D collaboration with ETH Zurich for advanced fleet optimization. | Complete vertical integration -- designs and manufactures all e-bikes, magnetic docking stations, and charging infrastructure in-house. Proprietary IoT connectivity embedded in every bike and station. Fifteen Control platform handles fleet management, diagnostics, and monitoring. |
How Does Levy Fleets Compare to Both?
Before deciding between ElectricFeel and Fifteen, consider Levy Fleets — a turnkey platform that delivers enterprise-grade features at a fraction of the cost, with no tiered feature gates on any plan.
| Category | Levy Fleets | ElectricFeel | Fifteen |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $250/mo | Contact for pricing | Contact for pricing (B2G only) |
| Pricing Model | Revenue share, per-vehicle, or self-managed — your choice | Enterprise SaaS with custom pricing | Municipal B2G contracts with modular service tiers |
| Feature Gating | None — full features on every plan | Varies by tier | Varies by tier |
| Minimum Fleet Size | No minimum | 100 | 100 |
| Setup Fees | $0 (white-label optional at $2,750) | Varies | Varies |
| Support | 24/7 US-based, included on all plans | Varies by plan | Varies by plan |
| Hardware Included | Yes — IoT pre-installed on all vehicles | No | Yes |
Levy Fleets includes payment processing, chargebacks, rider support, ID verification, push notifications, and marketing analytics on every plan — features that ElectricFeel and Fifteen either gate behind premium tiers or charge extra for.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | ElectricFeel | Fifteen |
|---|---|---|
| ElectricFeel Features | ||
| Customizable rider app (iOS & Android) with branded sounds, animations, and loading screens | ||
| Full-stack fleet management platform ("Shared Mobility OS") | ||
| Mobile field operations app for battery swapping and maintenance crews | ||
| Incentive Zones — dynamic pricing that shows riders discounted drop-off zones on the map to self-rebalance fleet | ||
| Battery swapping scheduling with part-time shift division | ||
| Centralized operations dashboard with data warehouse and BI analytics | ||
| Rider behavior heat maps and session conversion rate tracking | ||
| Customer care management platform with workflow automation | ||
| Re-engagement campaigns for dormant riders (claims 65% recovery rates) | ||
| Transit system and MaaS integration | ||
| Promo codes, offer management, and promotional incentive targeting | ||
| Subscription-based pricing support for riders | ||
| White-label branding with designer collaboration | ||
| Scalable from 100 to 10,000+ vehicles | ||
| Segway-Ninebot global hardware partnership for turnkey moped sharing | ||
| Service Area Optimization (SAO) — data-driven hub concentration for fleet efficiency | ||
| Sustainability metrics (claims 1M+ riders, 75M+ km traveled, 7,000+ tons CO2 saved) | ||
| Solar Impulse Foundation "Efficient Solution" label recipient | ||
| Fifteen Unique Features | ||
| Innovative magnetic docking system (from Zoov) -- ultra-compact stations | ||
| In-house manufactured electric bikes with dock charging | ||
| Fifteen Control fleet management platform | ||
| Fifteen Analytics with KPI tracking and reporting | ||
| Automatic fault diagnosis and 24/7 connected monitoring | ||
| Modular station deployment (no construction required for magnetic docks) | ||
| Short-term sharing and long-term rental on single platform | ||
| Public service contract expertise spanning 15+ years | ||
| Transit system integration for first-mile / last-mile | ||
| Multi-country deployment (France, Finland, Canada, Spain, Peru) | ||
| Unified platform addressing cities of all sizes | ||
| Turnkey operation option with Fifteen-managed staff | ||
Pricing Breakdown
ElectricFeel Pricing
No published pricing — entirely sales-led via "Book a Call" process. Custom enterprise SaaS contracts based on fleet size and scope. Typically serves operators with 100–10,000+ vehicles. With estimated revenue of ~$1.6M and a handful of active clients, average contract value is likely $150K–$400K/year for mid-size deployments. Launch timeline is 3–8 weeks for SaaS platform setup. No self-serve tier or free trial available. Implementation includes custom app branding (logos, colors, sounds, loading animations), training, and strategic operational guidance. No per-check verification fees documented, but no built-in ID verification either.
Fifteen Pricing
Custom enterprise contracts negotiated per city deployment. Three service levels: bike supply only (city operates), software only (city owns bikes), or full turnkey operation (Fifteen handles everything). Multi-year public service contracts typical. EUR 40M funding supports ongoing expansion. No public pricing -- all quotes require direct engagement with Fifteen sales team.
When to Choose Each Platform
Choose ElectricFeel if you...
- You already own vehicles and need sophisticated fleet management software with incentive-based rebalancing and battery swap scheduling
- You operate 100+ vehicles and need rider behavior analytics, heat maps, and dormant rider re-engagement campaigns claiming 65% recovery rates
- You are a transit company, utility, or enterprise fleet operator rather than a city government seeking a B2G turnkey contractor
- You want MaaS and transit system integration alongside Incentive Zone pricing to manage fleet distribution without heavy crew deployment
- You have budget for enterprise-level SaaS contracts and a multi-month implementation process with dedicated designer collaboration for white-label branding
- You operate in European or US smart cities and want a Solar Impulse-certified platform with an academic demand-forecasting heritage
Choose Fifteen if you...
- You are a city government procuring a docked e-bike network through public tender and need a single contractor to handle hardware, software, infrastructure, and operations
- You want Fifteen's magnetic docking stations that can be installed without construction or civil engineering work
- You need proven B2G public service contract experience across France, Finland, Canada, Spain, and Peru
- You operate or are deploying 100–20,000+ vehicles and want in-house manufactured electric bikes with dock-integrated charging
- You want both short-term sharing and long-term rental managed on a single platform under one B2G contract
- You prefer a turnkey operational model where Fifteen manages staffing, maintenance, and day-to-day operations
Looking for an Alternative to Both ElectricFeel and Fifteen?
Levy Fleets offers a turnkey fleet management solution with flexible pricing — revenue share (20% of GMV (15% at 100+ vehicles, annual terms)), per-vehicle ($14/mo at 100+, $12 at 500+, $9 at 1,000+), or self-managed — and the same full feature set on every plan. No tiered feature gates, no minimum fleet sizes, and US-based 24/7 support included.